Germany and Britain have rejected criticism from a senior Pentagon official of Ukraine’s long-range strikes inside Russia, exposing a widening split between Washington and Europe over how Kyiv should fight the war.
German defence minister Boris Pistorius called the US criticism “quite a stupid thing”. He said allies should instead talk about Russia’s “terroristic strikes every night and every day” on Ukraine’s energy, water and heating infrastructure.
The row broke out on Tuesday at a meeting of the Ukraine Defence Contact Group at Nato headquarters in Brussels, co-chaired by the UK and Germany, a day after Ukraine brought down part of the Kerch Bridge linking Russia to occupied Crimea.
Elbridge Colby, the US under secretary of defense for policy, told the meeting that Ukraine’s deep strikes were not working.
“While the public conversation focuses on the spectacle of deep strikes designed to inflict pain on the Russian population, our assessment is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia’s advances on the front line,” he said.
He singled out Ukrainian attacks on warehouses belonging to Wildberries, Russia’s largest online retailer, saying they had “actually probably hardened the Russian public’s resolve and the Kremlin’s own willingness to escalate”. Ukraine says the company supplies equipment used by Russia’s military, which Wildberries denies.
Colby said Western support should focus on helping Ukraine hold the front line and hit Russian supply routes with mid-range strikes, an approach he said had brought Ukraine gains in October. “This is not to say that Ukraine should be forced to fight with its hands tied behind its back,” he added.
Asked whether he shared Colby’s view, Pistorius said that “criticizing strikes like that in Russia to destroy strategic military and military-used targets” was “quite a stupid thing”.
“Instead of criticizing that, we should rather criticize and talk about the terroristic strikes every night and every day on energy, water, and heating infrastructure in Ukraine,” he said. “This is kind of terrorism.”
He drew a line between those Russian attacks and what he called “legal and legitimate” Ukrainian strikes on non-civilian targets inside Russia.
Germany, now one of Ukraine’s biggest backers, has previously lifted restrictions on how far its weapons can be used inside Russia.
UK Defence Secretary Wes Streeting, who co-chaired the meeting, took the same line. “It’s not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war,” he said.
“In terms of deep strike capability, there’s no doubt in my mind that it has helped to degrade Putin’s war machine, buying time and saving lives.”
Streeting also called for reliable satellite internet for Ukraine’s forces. “We do need to make sure that we have consistent and reliable service from Starlink and Starshield because lives depend on it,” he said.
Zelensky has warned that limits on Starshield, run by Elon Musk’s SpaceX, are costing lives and weakening Ukraine’s air defences as winter approaches. Asked about those restrictions after the meeting, Colby declined to comment. He said the US was “very focused on supporting Ukraine’s ability to defend itself”, without giving details.
Ukraine’s defence minister, Yevhenii Khmara, said its strikes were a response to Russian attacks since October, and pointed to the operation against the Crimea bridge.
“I want the Russian Federation to receive a clear signal: for every strike they launch against our territory, we will respond twice or three times as forcefully. And we have the right to defend ourselves,” he said.
He said Ukraine planned to more than triple its long-range strike capacity next year.
President Volodymyr Zelensky, addressing the meeting by video link, asked allies for more air defence interceptors. “Ukraine needs Patriot and IRIS-T interceptors from the stocks you already have right now,” he said, urging the US not to delay deliveries.
The clash is the latest sign of a growing gap between Washington and Europe over Ukraine. Under President Donald Trump, the US has stopped funding new arms for Kyiv, leaving European countries and Canada to pay for most of the weapons Ukraine receives.
Trump has also demanded that Ukraine stop attacking Russian oil refineries and diesel facilities, saying the strikes are worsening a global fuel shortage. Ukraine’s drone programme has allowed it to hit oil sites and other targets hundreds of miles inside Russia.
The row comes two days before Trump meets Vladimir Putin and Chinese leader Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, where he has said he expects to discuss the war. Ukraine fears the three leaders could make decisions about its future without it.
Russia, meanwhile, has stepped up its attacks on Ukraine’s power grid, leaving cities across the country with cuts to electricity, water and heating as winter begins.


