Rejoining the European Union in full could add £112bn a year to the UK economy in the long run, more than twice the gain from a single market deal, according to a new study.
The report, by the Productivity Institute think tank with Aston University’s Centre for Business Prosperity, compares the main options Prime Minister Andy Burnham is considering for rebuilding ties with Europe.
It was published as Burnham arrived in Brussels for a summit with EU leaders, where the two sides hope to sign deals on food trade, carbon pricing and youth visas.
The study, led by Professor Jun Du, estimates that full membership would raise UK economic output by up to 3.7% in the long term, worth £112bn a year at 2025 prices. That compares with £54bn for what it calls a “Swiss-style” deal to rejoin the single market, and £38bn for a customs union.
| Option | Long-term boost to GDP | Value per year (2025 prices) |
|---|---|---|
| Rejoin the EU in full | up to 3.7% | £112bn |
| Single market deal | 1.79% | £54bn |
| Customs union | 1.26% | £38bn |
The authors say the main gains would come from removing trade barriers and red tape on exports, and from a return of business investment held back by uncertainty since the 2016 referendum.
The benefits would take time. If the UK moved closer to the EU by 2035, about 80% of the potential gain would arrive within 15 years, with the full effect not felt until 2050. The estimates assume Burnham puts his plans to voters at the next general election, due by 2029, and wins a mandate to negotiate.
Burnham has said he wants a full rethink of the Brexit deal agreed by Boris Johnson. “It’s like the Emperor’s New Clothes, where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth,” he said in a speech in London this week. “The emperor has nothing on. The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained.”
He has floated four options: keeping the current arrangements; joining a customs union, which would remove tariffs on goods traded with the EU but mean applying its tariffs on everyone else; rejoining the single market, which would bring free movement of goods, services, money and people; or rejoining in full, which he has called “going all the way”.
He has said he will not propose rejoining in this parliament, and expects the next general election to test public support. He has also said any new deal would have to pass “the Makerfield test”, a reference to his own constituency near Manchester, which voted strongly to leave in 2016.
The study estimates the potential gain in economic output; it does not weigh the political trade-offs that come with each option. Jill Rutter, a senior fellow at the Institute for Government, said the in-between options carried heavy costs.
“The customs union means you give up some of your independent trading policy, [and] you have to apply EU tariffs for not very much gain,” she said. “The single market, you’d have to make a big contribution. You have to accept freedom of movement.”
She said the simplest options were probably to stay out or rejoin completely. “Do we really want to be subjected across the entire economy to EU rules and we’re not in the room?”
Rejoining would bring its own conditions. EU officials and diplomats are said to see any return as distant, and the opt-outs Britain once had, including from the euro, may not be available again. The EU’s foreign policy chief, Kaja Kallas, said “all our friends are welcome to join”, but that the decision was one for the British people.
Opponents are unconvinced. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch says rejoining would not “solve all our problems”, and Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has spent his political career campaigning against EU membership. Leave supporters also argue that Covid and the wars in Ukraine and the Middle East, rather than Brexit, explain much of the UK’s weak growth.
The study adds to a growing body of research on what Brexit has cost. A report co-written by Stanford University economist Nick Bloom and Bank of England economists in June estimated that the UK economy was about 6% smaller after a decade than it would have been inside the EU.
Public opinion has moved too. A YouGov survey of more than 4,000 people for the pro-EU group Best for Britain last year found 53% backed rejoining, with 32% against and 15% unsure. Other polls have shown similar majorities.
Some who voted Leave have changed their minds. Tim Chambers, a berry farmer who backed Brexit in 2016, told Australia’s ABC that exporting to Europe had become far harder. “Now you need to fill out 10 forms in duplicate,” he said. “And if you have one tick in the wrong box, then the whole shipment can be suspended.”
“I think I was naive to think that the politicians would come up with workable solutions,” he added.


