On Friday, Andy Burnham will sit down with Ursula von der Leyen and António Costa in Brussels and, if the last-minute haggling over student fees goes his way, sign three sensible agreements. Food will cross the Channel with less paperwork. British steelmakers will escape the EU’s new carbon charges. Young people will, eventually, be able to live and work in Lisbon or Lyon for a few years.
Each of these is worth having. Together, they tell us almost nothing about where Britain is going.
That is the real story of this summit. A decade after the referendum, Britain is quietly repairing the damage Brexit did, one agreement at a time. It is time to say plainly where this should lead: back into the European Union.
Ten years ago, voters were told that leaving would let Britain “take back control”, sign better trade deals around the world and free up money for the NHS, with a bus promising £350m a week.
The reality has been very different. Most economists agree that Brexit has hurt the economy by putting up barriers to trade with Britain’s nearest and largest market. The Office for Budget Responsibility has long assumed it will leave the country’s productivity about 4% lower over the long run than if it had stayed.
Exporters have been buried in paperwork, and some small food firms gave up selling to Europe altogether. Young people lost overnight the right to live, work and study across 27 countries.
Even the prime minister now says so. “The Brexit we were given has not worked,” Andy Burnham said this week. “We have lost more than we gained.”
The cruellest irony is what “control” now looks like. To make food trade easier, Britain will follow EU rules on animal and plant products, including on gene-edited crops and labelling, and drop its own planned ban on foie gras imports. To link carbon markets, it will align with EU rules there too. To rejoin the EU’s electricity market, the next deal on the list, it will pay into the EU budget.
So Britain will follow more EU rules and pay more EU money, with no vote on any of it. That is the opposite of taking back control. The only way to have a real say over the rules we already follow is to be back in the room where they are made.
Staying outside also weakens our hand. Because Britain is always the one asking, the EU sets the terms: tying Friday’s deals together to win concessions on student fees, and keeping British firms out of its “Made in Europe” plan for now.
Polls now suggest a majority of voters want to rejoin, and they deserve the truth about what that involves. The budget rebate Margaret Thatcher won would almost certainly be gone. New members are expected to commit, in principle, to adopting the euro, although Sweden has shown that commitment can stay on paper for decades. An opt-out from the Schengen border-free zone would have to be negotiated, and all 27 member states would have to agree.
Those are real hurdles. But weigh them against what membership would bring back: trade without borders with our biggest market, a vote on the rules we are already following, the freedom for young Britons to live and work across a continent, and a seat at the table when Europe decides how to face Russia and an unpredictable America.
The door is open. France’s Emmanuel Macron has said Britain would be welcome back. And the war in Ukraine has shown how much Europe needs Britain’s military strength, and how much Britain needs Europe.
Opponents deserve an answer. Michael Gove argues that rejoining “would mean handing back control of our laws, borders, money and trade, and paying a good deal more for membership than we did before”.
But Britain is already accepting EU rules without a vote, and paying for access. Membership would return the say we gave away. As for cost, the price of Brexit, in lost trade, investment and growth, has been far higher than any membership fee.
Kemi Badenoch accuses Burnham of “reopening the divisions and debates” of 2016. Yet those divisions never closed. What erodes trust is pretending the question is settled while signing up to EU rules by the back door. An honest, open choice is how a country moves on.
Burnham has promised to set out the long-term options after this summit, while keeping Labour’s red lines until the next election. That caution is understandable, but it must not become an excuse for drift.
He should use those options to make the positive case for membership, with the costs, benefits and timelines laid out honestly. And Labour should put rejoining in its next manifesto, as former deputy prime minister David Lammy has urged, so that voters can give a clear mandate.
The EU will want proof that Britain means it this time. Ireland’s ambassador, Sonja Hyland, said this week that Britain must “make a clear decision as to what it wants”. Then let us make it.
Leaving was sold as a fresh start. It turned out to be a wrong turn. Friday’s deals are a welcome step back.


